graphic designer graphic designer andrew keir

Some logo designs are not for you

.

metal logo design

The popular corporate and brand identity review blog, Brand New, posted an article a while back on logo designs and branding of the music and sub-culture of black and death metal music.

While this obviously not everyone’s cup of tea, some of the feedback was a little unexpected. Many of the readers of Brand New are design savvy, as a result comments and conversations are usually fairly constructive, but not this time.

Here are a few examples of the logo designs in question:

metal music logo 1

metal music logo 2

metal music logo 3

metal music logo 4

Many readers who by there own admission have no interest or understanding of the genre, were quick to dismiss the entire thing as a garbled mess. While a few enthusiasts were quick to rise to their defence, most seemed keen to condemn without a second thought.

What do you think?

Obviously they’re not for everyone, but then they were never meant to be.

Subscribe to the RSS feed or get updates via email.

4 thoughtful comments on “Some logo designs are not for you”

  1. Derek says:

    Although cool individually, they’re all so very redundant and perfectly symmetrical.

  2. Omar says:

    I like the detail in the second one.

  3. Andrew Keir says:

    Derek,

    Since when is symmetry a bad thing?

  4. Great Title, it says all. Perhaps I find the designs you have shared inspiring because I am fan of typography and these resemble typographic artwork. I particularly like the concept of second one.

What do you think?


PLEASE NOTE: To prevent spam, your first comment will be moderated so there may be a short delay before it appears. Feel free to leave your thoughts on multiple posts, and they will all appear in no time.

Welcome!

My name is Andrew Keir, I am a graphic designer and brand identity consultant working with clients around the world.

I’m currently available for hire. Feel free to contact me, review my graphic design portfolio or just browse my blog.

Start your graphic design project
Subscribe and connect
Categories
Sponsored by

Sitemap.

© 2011 Andrew Keir. Branding, identity, logo, and graphic designer. Keysborough, Melbourne, Victoria.